Home
/
Expert opinions
/
Thought leadership
/

Peter schiff critiques bitcoin's 40% drop against gold

Peter Schiff | Bitcoin Faces Fall with 40% Loss Against Gold

By

Nina Dupont

Nov 19, 2025, 05:41 AM

Edited By

Alice Turner

2 minutes needed to read

Peter Schiff speaking about Bitcoin's drop against gold in a financial discussion
popular

A fierce debate brews in the investment community, as Peter Schiff, a prominent critic of Bitcoin, claims the cryptocurrency's recent drop of over 40% against gold undermines its standing as "digital gold". Schiff's comments have sparked considerable disagreement among crypto advocates, many of whom stand firmly behind Bitcoin's long-term prospects.

The Controversy Ignites

In a bold statement, Schiff urges investors to consider selling their Bitcoin assets and shifting their focus to gold, asserting that the digital currency could continue to decline. He also took shots at Michael Saylor's Bitcoin-centric business model, warning it may lead to bankruptcy. It's a classic battle of ideologies: crypto versus commodities.

"This sets dangerous precedent," said one commenter, expressing disdain for Schiff's criticisms.

Supporters Rally

Despite the bearish sentiment from Schiff, many in the cryptocurrency community emphasize that such volatility is normal for Bitcoin. They argue that price fluctuations don't diminish Bitcoin's long-term value. Reflecting this sentiment, another user stated:

"Lookup XAU/BTC 1 year performance and then look at 5 yr performance. That 40% this year is a tiny mini pump compared to how Bitcoin has flexed on Gold for the last 5 years."

Diverging Opinions on Investments

This topic has illuminated a divide among people regarding asset allocation. Many express the importance of diversification, mixing crypto, gold, stocks, and bonds as a sound investment strategy. As one supporter put it,

"Whatever, everyone should diversify and own a bit of crypto, gold, stocks, bonds, etc."

Key Insights

  • β–³ Schiff's claim highlights Bitcoin's significant volatility, igniting debate over its legitimacy.

  • β–½ Supporters maintain that Bitcoin's long-term trajectory remains strong despite short-term fluctuations.

  • β€» "He can’t keep getting away with this!!" - Reactions to Schiff's continued criticism.

The ongoing discourse illustrates a broader theme of conflict among different investment philosophies as 2025 progresses. Will Bitcoin bounce back, or is golden stability the way forward? Only time will tell.

What Lies Ahead for Bitcoin and Gold

There's a strong chance Bitcoin may continue to experience volatility in the near term, particularly as critiques like Schiff's gain traction. Experts estimate around a 60% probability that market reactions could force some investors to reconsider their positions, possibly leading to a temporary dip in prices. On the other hand, the long-term prospects of Bitcoin remain robust, with advocates pushing a narrative of resilience. If the crypto market can stabilize after this setback, it may reclaim its status as a hedge against inflation, potentially attracting more institutional investment by the end of 2025. Given the current trends, we might see consolidation around cryptocurrencies as people seek alternatives to traditional investments like gold, heralding a shift in asset allocation trends.

A Lesson from the Unfolding Tech Landscape

This situation echoes the rise and fall of early internet companies during the late 1990s, where speculative investments led to both massive booms and catastrophic busts. Just as investors once dismissed the measurable value of firms like Amazon and eBay during their initial tumultuous periods, today’s skeptics may be overlooking Bitcoin's underlying potential as a transformative technology. What started as a volatile digital asset has much more in common with those pioneering firms than many realize. Like the dot-com bust that paved the way for digital giants, Bitcoin's current challenges may eventually give rise to a more stable and mature cryptocurrency market.